When Greta Gerwig’s Barbie was in its early casting stages, one surprising name surfaced as a potential lead: Blake Lively. While Margot Robbie ultimately landed the iconic role, Lively was reportedly in contention, thanks to her Hollywood status and past collaborations with co-star America Ferrera in The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. With a career defined by glamour and poise, Lively seemed like a natural fit for Barbie’s plastic-fantastic world. However, behind the scenes, tensions arose that ultimately led to her missing out on the blockbuster.

Blake Lively’s Big Ambitions

Unlike the other actresses who joined the film with an ensemble mindset—such as Dua Lipa and Hari Nef—Blake Lively reportedly had grander aspirations. Rather than accepting a supporting role within the Barbie universe, sources claim she pushed for more creative control and a more significant on-screen presence. This approach conflicted with the film’s vision, which prioritized collaboration and an egalitarian portrayal of its characters.

Lively’s insistence on having a larger say in the storytelling process is nothing new. The actress has often expressed her desire to be involved beyond just acting, whether in writing, costume design, or shaping the narrative. While this level of engagement can be an asset in some projects, it seems that in Barbie, it was seen as overstepping.

Margot Robbie’s Swift Response

Margot Robbie, who not only played the titular role but also served as a producer through her company, LuckyChap Entertainment, had a clear vision for Barbie. She wanted to create a collaborative and positive environment on set, fully aligned with Greta Gerwig’s artistic direction. When Lively started pushing for changes, Robbie reportedly shut down negotiations, unwilling to risk derailing the project.

This move was a calculated one. Robbie has built a reputation in Hollywood as someone who values professionalism and creative harmony. She wasn’t about to let internal conflicts jeopardize the film’s development. Unlike typical Hollywood casting dramas, this situation was handled quietly and efficiently, ensuring that Barbie remained drama-free and focused on delivering its message.

A Pattern of Power Struggles

Lively’s Barbie rejection wasn’t the only time she faced resistance over her desire for creative input. Her involvement in It Ends With Us has also been marred by similar tensions. Reports suggest that she pushed for significant script changes, leading to frustration among the production team, including director Justin Baldoni. The situation allegedly escalated to the point of legal complications, further highlighting the difficulties of Lively’s approach in high-profile projects.

Did Blake Lively Miss Out, or Did Margot Robbie Make the Right Call?

Looking at the success of Barbie, it’s clear that Robbie’s instincts were correct. The film grossed over a billion dollars and became a cultural phenomenon, with no apparent void that Lively would have filled. Her absence didn’t detract from the film’s impact, further proving that Robbie’s decision to keep the production streamlined was the right one.

Additionally, Lively’s history with former co-stars and industry figures suggests that her desire for control may be alienating some colleagues. Anna Kendrick, who worked with Lively on A Simple Favor, reportedly requested solo interviews during the sequel’s press tour. Even America Ferrera, once close to Lively, hasn’t publicly mentioned her in years. If these patterns continue, it raises the question: Is Blake Lively burning too many bridges in Hollywood?

The Future of Blake Lively in Hollywood

Hollywood is an industry built on relationships, trust, and collaboration. Margot Robbie has mastered the balance of influence and professionalism, allowing her to rise as one of the most powerful women in the industry. Lively, on the other hand, risks being sidelined if she continues to prioritize control over cooperation.

With It Ends With Us facing scrutiny and Barbie thriving without her, Lively’s Hollywood strategy is under more pressure than ever. Will she adapt to industry expectations, or will she continue to push for more power at the risk of further alienation? At this point, Hollywood seems to be making its choice—and it’s not in her favor.